Thursday, 17 April 2014

Gender Mainstreaming

There are several areas relating to water which concern women, such as domestic water supply or irrigation water use where women are the owners of the irrigated lands, but women are excluded in matters pertaining to water development and management. Women are virtually absent form public sector departments that deal with water. The NGO sector has limited participation of women as does the private sector. Although women are not formally banned from joining the Water User Association (WUAs), they do not find a representation in them. Irrigation management is generally considered to be the domain of men. There has been some effort to involve women in village level committees that are organized for the provision of domestic water supply and sanitation. These efforts need to be strengthened and built upon.
 
Core Challenges/Issues
 
  • How do we ensure that aspirations of both genders are incorporated in the decision-making regarding the planning, management, operation and maintenance of water resources.
  • How do we ensure participation of women and the more vulnerable section of society in decision-making of water resources that directly impacts their workload, productivity and incomes.
  • How do we ensure equal access to both genders in their allocation and use of water resources.
 
Core Objective
  • The existing gender disparities in Pakistan are so severe that they first need to be rectified through a focused approach which directly improves women's access, decision-making and participation in the use, management and development of water resources. To recognize that women's needs are legitimate and deserve the same level of consideration as those of other users.
  • Once the above is achieved, to mainstream  gender perspective in the water sector to ensure that the interests and needs of women as well as those of men are systematically pursued in the development of all national/regional policies and programs. Attention to gender issues should not be confined to a sector called "Women's Development" or addressed through isolated or marginal programs within the water sector
  • Ensuring effective women's participation in decision-making at all levels regarding water resources and in decisions which directly or indirectly impact their workload, productivity and incomes.
Strategies
  • Greater awareness raising about the necessity of incorporating gender concerns and a gender orientation in institutions dealing with the water sector.
  • Creation of institutional forums at the village and neighborhood level which enable female participation and representation in the use of village level resources.
  • Enhance the incentives and opportunities for women professionals to join the public and private sector institutions dealing with water sector.
Proposed Action
 
  • Build capacity to increase the understanding of gender implications for water management, as part of an effort to empower women so that they can acquire the skills to enter water management at a senior level. This involves an increase in technical and scientific education offered to women.
  • A proactive effort to gender sensitize water management approaches at senior policy making levels in national structure as part of a strategy to ensure equity and increased women's involvement in these process.
  • Genre training for men and women working in water-related national and regional bodies, non-governmental organizations and private water companies.

Research and Development (R&D)

The effective with which the myriad actions with multiple dimensions are carried out to achieve the country's Water Vision, would depend upon the soundness with which the actions are conceive. This represents the need for information derived from research and whose practical applicability has been demonstrated. Research has been carried out and continues to be carried out by separate disciplines with a narrow focus without the full realization that the application of the research results has to pass through a technological stage and has to pass test of social acceptability. In this environment basic research has to be integrated with technological development and the consideration of sociological and economic aspects for putting the findings into practice.
 
There are many areas of research impacting on water development and its effective utilization, some of which such as desalinization of water or production of energy from unconventional sources require massive investments in research. Within the limited resources, in a country such as Pakistan, the research effort therefore has to be limited to the adoption of known research results through appropriate technologies using pilot programmes and demonstration project.
 
Core Objectives
 
The core objective in R&D can be stated as the networking of the existing research institutions to develop practical solutions to the problems in an integrated framework, while making the best use of the research results from around the word.
 
Strategies
 
The strategies which can be followed for an effective R&D initiative are:
 
  • Redefining the roles of the existing research institutions so as to establish a complimentarily in their working
  • Establishing networks of research institutes in specific research areas and assigning the lead role to the institute with the most comparative advantage.
  • Developing research agendas which would support the FFA.
  • Establishing a close coordination between the implementing agencies and research institutes.
 
Proposed Action
 
  • Entrust to the PCRWR (Pakistan Council of Research in Water Research) the lead role for developing in cooperation with all development agencies, a National Research Agenda.
  • Establish a limited number of research network for specific topics impacting on the FFA.


 
 

Wednesday, 16 April 2014


Institution

There are many institutions working in the Water Sector in Pakistan which include Federal and Provincial Organizations, public agencies, semi-autonomous bodies, corporations, NGOs and community organizations. However, water use and management is undertaken in a manner which is very subject specific. Thus the institutions dealing with irrigation water, domestic water supply, hydropower generation, industrial water supply and waste water disposal are all separate. For a holistic approach for the need for a broad integration in the water sector.
 
The institutions as they exist, with centralized decision-making structure and lack of accountability, face common problems of low delivery efficiency, high O&M costs, low cost recovery and consequent poor maintenance of infrastructure. what is more, the institutions have a limited charter, with aspects relating to planning, monitoring and evaluation, financing and pricing being left to other agencies. The institutions, by and large are insolated from the beneficiaries of their operations and there are no mechanisms whereby the grievances of the affected people could be rectified. this highlights the need for the active participation of the stakeholders in decision-making in a meaningful manner. These institutional problems needs to be addressed urgently in Pakistan.
 
Core Challenges/Issues
 
  • Integrated Water Resources Management: How do we restructure the existing institutional infrastructure for water in a manner that is conductive to integrated water resource management. Do we consider it necessary to create new institutional arrangements or is it possible to work within the existing system for greater integration of the water sector.
  • Conservation & Efficiency: How we change the orientation of the staff of our institutions and create a system of incentives that will be more conservation oriented in terms of use of water and enhance the efficiency of the system.
  • Sustainability: How do we preserve the investment in the physical infrastructure in the water sector, recover costs for water use and the operation and maintenance of the system and ensure community participation in scheme planning, management and maintenance for sustainability.
  • Gender Concerns: How do we incorporate the concerns of women and the poor in institutions that are not only male dominted but in which the participation of women is negligible and there is no field staff and no institutions forum at the village level for the participation of women equivalent to the Water User Association, etc. Furthermore the concerns of the poor and the more vulnerable sections of society are not reflected either.

Core Objective
 
  • Coordinating the activities of all the institutions dealing with water or impacting on water, at the Federal and Provincial levels for ensuring integrated water resource development and management.
  • introducing institutions reforms to allow for the participation of stakeholders in decisions making. Enhancing institutional efficiency through monitoring, evaluation and feed back, while ensuring accountability and transparency.
  • Monitoring of performance of institutions.
Strategies
  • Integrated water resources management through networking and reinforcing a networking idea among partners and through integrated planning which looks upon the basin as a unit. The establishment of a fully independent body which is de-politicized and can act as the custodian for the use, management and development of water resources in an integrated manner.
  • Involving the stakeholders in the decision-making functions of the institutions.
  • Introducing transparency in the working of the institution.
  • Introducing performance criteria and system of rewards and punishment based on them.
Proposed Actions
  • The Planning Division at the Federal level and the Planning and Development Department at the Provincial Level should develop in constitution with concerned agencies mechanisms for integrating the functions in the water sector, so that the inter-related issues could be continually kept in review and steps evolved to deal with them.
  • Critically review the working of the existing institutions in water, through institutional studies, to determine the changes required for improving the performance.
  • Introducing a system of performance monitoring of the institutions for needed actions by the controlling public bodies.

Thursday, 10 April 2014

POLICY PRESCRIPTION & IMPLEMENTATION
 
 
Core Issues
 
At present there is no comprehensive water policy, Policies that are in vogue, are derived largely from the laws that had been promulgated for specific matters relating to water use and which are not necessarily inter-related. Policy prescriptions have been laid down from time to time for some aspects relating to water. In this disjointed policy framework recognition of and coherence to fundamental principal is lacking. Moreover all the policies have been imposed without involving those who may be affected by them. As a result disputes pertaining to water use its development have continue and continue to impact on future development and inefficiencies in water use are being perpetrated.
 
 
Core Objectives
 
 
The core objective is to develop, with the broadest consensus, a comprehensive Water Policy which would lead to sustainable and the most effective utilization and conservation of all the available water resources for the benefit of all the people of the country.
 
 
Strategies
 
 
For evolving the comprehensive Water Policy while involving those who would be affected by it the following strategies are proposed:-
 
  • Fostering the formulation of "water users groups" by the concerned organizations at different levels.
  • Information dissemination to the "water users groups" on the present policy (and laws) and their implications.
  • Studies, on all policy elements, which should be covered by the comprehensive policy and discussion thereon by the concerned water users and the interacting agencies (studies under the NDP are a step in the right directions).
  • Drafting of Draft Policy and nation wide deliberation thereon.
Proposed Action

The Federal Government through the Planning Division, should initiate the process of policy formulation, actively involving the Provincial Governments and other stakeholders so that the policy could be adopted in a period of 3 years.

The process of policy formulation should be taken up connectivity with a review of the existing laws so as to define the legal framework which should be put in place to give affect to the policy.

 
 
 


STRATEGIES
 
 
Mobilizing political will and commitment for good governance at the highest level as the key for sustainable and efficient management of the water sector. As such the principal strategy will be to secure the participation and commitment of our political leaders.
 
 
Proposed Action
 
 
Secure the commitment  of the political leadership and government line agencies to the objectives through a program of awareness raising, information dissemination, system of rewards and punishments.

GOVERNANCE
 
The and planning machinery of the public sector in Pakistan is highly centralized. Similarly, the water sector is characterized by centralized decision-making in terms of all major decisions regarding the fixing of water rates, collection and assessment system, operation and maintenance, etc. The centralized system of decision-making was fueled by the failure of the government to invest in local level institutions and emerging problems. The local institutions were unable to fill the void that existed at the grass roots level. In the early 1990s there was a realization that the state system had failed on several accounts. The limited resources available to the public sector also indicated the extent to which the State had over committed itself. The record of both economic and political governance in Pakistan was poor and under successive regimes it has become even weaker. The governance of the water sector in symptomatic of this poor record in governance. Pakistan today stands at the threshold of a crisis in the water sector perpetuated by this failure to govern effectively.
 
Core Challenges/Issues
 
How do we ensure that the interests of those who are governed are served and protected by those who govern.
 
How do we ensure that the powers, instruments and tools of governance which are placed at the disposal of those who govern will not be misused and will be used to serve the national interest and protect the rights of the citizens.
 
How do we develop and manage our water resources in a more effective and intelligent manner in the face of competing demand.
 
How do we make the distribution of our water resources equitable.
 
How do we make the investments in the physical infrastructure for water sustainable.
 
How do we put in place effective and impartial mechanisms for conflict resolution acceptable to all parties.
 
Core Objectives
 
To have a vibrant civil society in which the NGOs, private sector, local communities and other representative of civil society actively collaborate to achieve the overall objectives of sustainable development in the country and in which the government will facilitate the process of negotiation and consensus building through an appropriate policy framework and from direct intervention to providing appropriate market signals.
 
To ensure that the interests of those who are governed are served and protected by those who govern.
 
To ensure that the powers, instruments and tools of governance which are placed at the disposal of those who govern are not be misused and will be used to serve the national interest and protect the rights of the citizens.

Monday, 7 April 2014

OVERARCHING ELEMENTS
 
The Pakistan Water Vision has as its overall objective the attainment of a status in which water resources development and management is integrated and sustainable. For this purpose the formulation of FFA provides the opportunity of putting into practice the accepted principles of integrated Water Resources Management (IWRM) and the concept to managing water at the basin level.
 
 
IWRM does not merely represent the integration of the different uses that are made of water (irrigation, drinking water, industrial use, the ecological function of water etc.) to take account of the way they influence each other. It is a concept that is much broder and which aims at establishing a sound basis for sustainable water use taking into consideration all the social and economic factors -- Governance Institutions, Management Instruments,  Financial aspects, Technologies, Research requirements, Capacity Building and Participation of all section of the society including women or Mainstreaming of Gender.
 
While for all water related activities, at the sectoral or sub-sectoral level, a holistic approach is required with full cognizance of IWRM, there is a need for an "Umbrella" under which these activities are pursued and which provides the guiding beacon. This aspect has been treated here, as the overarching elements, confined to those elements which are most relevant.